May is our anniversary month. This May brings our 14th…on the 16th. With wedding season in full swing, open May weekends are a rarity, except this past weekend when Meghann and I were given the opportunity for a date night from one of our favorite local businesses called Babysitting By Nina (a.k.a., grandma needed some Mollie time). Double win.
Our date night appetizer consisted of an outdoor tango lesson in Centennial Park, a first for both of us (and we’re hooked), before dinner reservations at 1808 Grille just down the street. Housed in the super cool Hutton Hotel, our first dining experience at 1808 Grille was a hit. An amazingly delicious hit.
“One of the very nicest things about life is the way we must regularly stop
whatever it is we are doing and devote our attention to eating.”
~Luciano Pavarotti

Photo from www.1808grille.com; photographer unknown
Cue the adjective onslaught….
We were greeted at the door by two smiling hostesses bedecked in classic little black dresses then seated at a comfortable table to peruse a sophisticated wine list (1808 Grille has been the recipient of Wine Spectator Award of Excellence three years running) featuring select fine wines from around the world. We chose Centine…a youthful and intensely fruity blend of Sangiovese, Cabernet Sauvignon, and Merlot…from Castello Banfi in our favorite Tuscan village called Montalcino. Cheers to us!
The deliciousness started with a remarkable salad. “Salad” doesn’t even come close to describing this collection of artisanal greens sourced from a local farmer tossed in a house-made buttermilk dressing including mayo, buttermilk, garlic, oregano, basil, parsley, and cayenne pepper accompanied by salami bacon, dried corn, shaved red onion, golden raisins, and curry spiced cracker. Harmonious explosion of striking flavors.

The famed Classic Braised Short Rib. Photo provided by 1808 Grille.
The decadence continued with the main courses. Meghann furthered our love affair with Italy via Five Cheese Tortellini…Tuscan kale, shaved garlic, Roma tomato, crimini mushrooms, and Pinot Grigio. This dish didn’t disappoint, though it played supporting actor to the menu’s most favorite character…the famed Classic Braised Short Rib.
I’m not much of a red meat devotee, but this entrée changed that. The beef short ribs are slow braised for about three hours in a moist cooking environment until tender (i.e. side-of-fork tender; no knife required) topped with a demi-glace of mirepoix (combination of chopped onion, carrot, and celery), tomato paste, red wine, and veal stock. The flavor so intensely indescribable must be experienced for yourself. These short ribs even had a sidekick popover, a puff pastry stuffed with a horseradish cream. Magical pairing.
Sides of the day included a trio of Mac & Cheese (made with cheddar, jack, parmesan, and roasted red peppers), Wine-braised Mushrooms (cooked with Cabernet, red onions, and red wine vinegar then finished with just a little rosemary), and Tomato & Cucumber Salad of very fresh local ingredients including lightly sautéed ramps, shaved breakfast radishes, and chimichurri (shallot, garlic, parsley, oregano, champagne vinegar).
Such a meal would be incomplete without dessert, right? Server recommendations included Banana Beignets with a Hazelnet Glaze and Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie, both of which tempted our tastebuds, which we treated to the super-sophisticated version of that magical combination brought mainstream by the legendary H.B. Reese himself. Plus cappuccino for good measure, of course.
Executive Chef Charles Phillips (recently invited to cook at the prestigious James Beard House in Manhattan) and Executive Sous Chef Jake Strang were in fine form for this dinner. Outstanding table service throughout the entire evening, plus a brief chat with Assistant General Manager John Baskett, rounded out a wonderful dining experience with my everbride.
This anniversary dinner was quite an outstanding experience, and I can highly recommend 1808 Grille for a cosmopolitan proposal evening, sophisticated rehearsal dinner, or decadent precursor to your bachelor/bachelorette party. And in the spirit of all delicious things Italian…Buon Appetito!
